Free Legal Case Evidence Catalog Rubric Template
Legal Case Evidence Catalog Rubric
This rubric is designed to assist in the organization and evaluation of evidence for legal cases handled by [Your Company Name]. It encompasses various types of evidence commonly encountered in legal proceedings. The table below provides both the categories and their respective descriptions of what constitutes each rating level.
|
Category |
Excellent (4) |
Good (3) |
Fair (2) |
Poor (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Document Evidence |
Documents are highly relevant, authentic, and well-supported. |
Documents are mostly relevant and authentic but may have minor issues. |
Some relevance or authenticity issues with documents. |
Documents are largely irrelevant, unreliable, or inadmissible. |
|
Witness Testimony |
Witnesses are credible, consistent, and provide crucial information. |
Witnesses are generally credible and provide valuable information, with minor inconsistencies. |
Witnesses may have credibility issues or significant inconsistencies. |
Witnesses lack credibility, consistency, or provide irrelevant information. |
|
Physical Evidence |
Physical evidence is well-preserved, relevant, and properly documented. |
Physical evidence is mostly relevant and documented but may have minor preservation issues. |
Some relevance or documentation issues with physical evidence. |
Physical evidence is poorly preserved, irrelevant, or inadequately documented. |
|
Expert Opinions |
Expert opinions are highly credible, well-supported, and relevant. |
Expert opinions are generally credible and relevant, with minor gaps or issues. |
Some credibility or relevance issues with expert opinions. |
Expert opinions lack credibility, relevance, or are unreliable. |
