Document Evidence

Documents are highly relevant, authentic, and well-supported.

Documents are mostly relevant and authentic but may have minor issues.

Some relevance or authenticity issues with documents.

Documents are largely irrelevant, unreliable, or inadmissible.

Witness Testimony

Witnesses are credible, consistent, and provide crucial information.

Witnesses are generally credible and provide valuable information, with minor inconsistencies.

Witnesses may have credibility issues or significant inconsistencies.

Witnesses lack credibility, consistency, or provide irrelevant information.

Physical Evidence

Physical evidence is well-preserved, relevant, and properly documented.

Physical evidence is mostly relevant and documented but may have minor preservation issues.

Some relevance or documentation issues with physical evidence.

Physical evidence is poorly preserved, irrelevant, or inadequately documented.

Expert Opinions

Expert opinions are highly credible, well-supported, and relevant.

Expert opinions are generally credible and relevant, with minor gaps or issues.

Some credibility or relevance issues with expert opinions.

Expert opinions lack credibility, relevance, or are unreliable.