Academic Peer Review Feedback Form

Name

Anonymous review is optional.

Affiliation

Area of Expertise

Title of the Work

Date Reviewed

Does the work present original ideas or contribute new knowledge to the field?

Is the research topic relevant and significant within its academic field?

Is the writing clear, concise, and well-organized?

Are the research methods appropriate, rigorous, and well-documented?

Are the data, arguments, and conclusions accurate and well-supported?

Does the work demonstrate a thorough understanding of existing research?

Does the submission follow the required academic or formatting standards?

Strengths of the Work

Areas for Improvement

Recommendation

• Accept without Changes

• Minor Revisions Required

• Major Revisions Required

• Reject

Additional Comments